Banjo Shuckers: The Perfect Oyster Knife for Beginners (and pros)

Banjo Shuckers: The Perfect Oyster Knife for Beginners (and pros)

“Oysters are the one food that people will cross a room to tell you they don’t like.”

Knifewear staff got a special treat recently: a training course in oyster shucking by none other than Jason Woodside, the owner of Banjo Oyster Shuckers! These shuckers speak for themselves in regard to quality and ease of use, but I'd like to share what we learned about these incredible tools. 

Let me start by saying Jason is astonishing. With 28 years of experience shucking oysters, several million shucked, he’s one of the best in Canada, if not the world. Competitions, high-volume shucking, two-time winner of the Canadian shucking competition, all while teaching at least 5000 people to shuck oysters over the years. He’s done everything from sea to table. 

As he was teaching, he kept noticing folks struggling: using too much pressure, fighting shuckers that didn’t feel good in their hands. He found that many beginners were struggling with the motion that pops the oyster open. This got him thinking: what would help people get the hang of it? 

Every beginner trips over the same problem: they couldn’t find the right spot to pry. If they failed to make the shucker bite into the hinge, people resorted to brute force. I related to this a lot, but as I listened to Jason talk about leverage v.s. force, it made an awful lot of sense: if you try to shuck with a dull knife, you won’t get the shucker to bite into the right spot. As we tried again with his expert advice, I was shocked how little force is required to open an oyster the right way. 

As Jason started designing his first batch of shuckers, he kept picturing folks like me struggling with their oysters. He had a mental image of the blade shape that would fix the struggle, but he couldn’t find them anywhere - so he set to work grinding them by hand. A pointier knife that would easily bite into the hinge of the oyster. He paired this unique design with handles that nestle into your hand for better grip, crafted from softer materials to provide comfort and reduce strain. and 

His first shucker was born: The Banjo. He started with a skateboard wheel for the handle, bought a whole pack of them. The wheel allows you to hold the shucker in the most natural position for your arm. But buying the wheels didn’t quite work, so he started working with a two-part epoxy resin handle (which, by the way, Jason is collecting; if you still have one, let him know.) After a while, wood started to make more sense; the resin was really hard on the hands over long hours of shucking without a glove. He likened hours spent working with the resin handles (and poly material handles in general) to driving a car with no shocks or wearing flip-flops to walk around Manhattan for a day. The current wood design he eventually landed on offers significantly better grip, a really beautiful aesthetic, and overall greater comfort, even after hours of use. 

The banjo is nice and light; it sits in your hand like it was meant to fit there. I have shucked maybe a dozen oysters compared to Jason’s estimated 4 million- but he was right: the twisting motion was much easier than prying, getting the point to bite into the shell was simpler, and I could finally see that I have been using too much force in my previous attempts. I was working so much harder than I needed to. I also found the wood handles get slightly grippy, and easier to keep a hold of when water hits them- and this is by design. The grains lift ever so slightly, creating a grippy texture that won’t slip on you mid-oyster.

Jason describes the banjo as the perfect shucker for beginners and gifters. Not only are they great to use, but they’re also really beautiful. He gets all his hardwoods from PEI, and all of Jason’s oyster shuckers are not only made entirely by hand but also sharpened entirely by hand!

Jason’s second shucker design is the islander pro. Designed for service, high volume and efficiency while prioritizing comfort. It takes a bit of practice, but once you get the hang of it, it takes a lot of the work out of shucking. Even as a beginner, I found it nice to use; the bulb handle has a great flat spot, so when you are shucking and looking up to talk to customers or your dinner party guests, you don’t have to look at the shucker. You have a reference point to get it centred in your hand the way you like without even a glance in its direction. The handle is still relatively short, so it tucks into your hand.

The bulb-style handle is much less natural in your hand than the banjo, because it places your hand, forearm and blade on different axes. This means you have to engage different muscles in your arm and in your hand, making it a lot harder for beginners. It’s not that beginners can’t use these incredible tools, but it's much harder to learn on than the banjo. Ultimately, the banjo is designed for beginners, and I think you can guess who the Islander Pro is meant for. Jason explains that giving a beginner an islander pro is like teaching a 16-year-old to drive stick. Better to give them a tool they won’t struggle so much to use, so they can get comfortable and confident with the process.

Much like we do at Knifewear, Jason talks about the advantages and disadvantages of harder steel: harder steel offers better edge retention but is more likely to chip. Especially when you store your shucker in the ice! Jason cannot stress enough how easily you will chip or snap your shucker this way. It’s well known that steel conducts temperature very easily, and cold makes things brittle. SO while it may be very convenient, store your shuckers and tools on a dry towel instead of in the ice. Especially when shucking for an audience, the towel signifies that it is your tool for the task you are doing, not something for folks to pick up.

For both shuckers, he uses 306 stainless steel; it offers the perfect amount of flexibility, and it also has a great balance between sharpness and durability. Blade flex is really handy when shucking. Jason says stiffer blades have their place, but a little flex is a great way to tell if you are applying too much pressure. If you start seeing that blade flexing, you probably haven’t found the perfect spot to open the oyster.

Here’s what Jason had to say about this: “Blade flex is a valuable tool for determining the amount of pressure you’re applying on the oyster! Why does that matter? Because the oysters have changed over the last 30 years. 28 years ago we shucked predominantly wild or bottom-grown oysters; they had heavier shells! You could push a spoon in there and paint-can it open!”

As we quizzed our new oyster shucking friend, he explained a lot I hadn’t realized about oysters; most of the oysters we get these days are aqua-cultured. Aquaculture is a sustainable way of raising oysters. They start out at a hatchery, then mature in bags or trays in coastal waters. This results in them having thinner shells that grow in layers like tree rings, and these layers aren’t perfect. They have small inconsistencies, so more shell tends to flake off as compared to the early days of Jason’s shucking journey. That’s what makes getting the right spot and pressure so important; if you don’t, you get more breakage of the shell, which means bits of shell in your oyster. Crunchy shell really ruins the experience of eating an oyster. 

Now, one of the big questions I asked him and was grateful for the answer to. East Coast oysters are going through a really hard time right now; how can we oyster fans help out? Are East Coast oysters still okay to eat? 

East Coast oysters are getting decimated by two deadly diseases; this is killing the oyster populations at a terrifying rate. But what I hadn’t realized is that this has happened before. About 100 years ago, by Jason’s estimation, the oyster population out East went through a very similar incident. Everything did recover, and now there is a well-established plan. The diseases affecting these oysters have no effect on humans, what really affects us is that East Coast oysters don’t last as long as they normally would. So if you buy them, you are looking at eating them the night of- maybe the day after. Jason shared one main piece of advice: PLEASE keep buying East Coast oysters. The support will help keep the oyster farmers afloat until the next season. Once this round has all died out, then they can “reseed.” Jason mentioned that there are already groups raising money for the various farmers to cover reseeding costs. I am a huge East Coast oyster fan, so I was really relieved to hear that not only can I help, but the biggest thing I can do is continue to enjoy the incredible oysters. When more news comes out about fundraising, you can be sure I’ll be one of the first to find some way to donate. This is something we Canadians take a lot of pride in, since both our coasts give us these tidal treasures. 

Even as a novice oyster shucker, it is remarkable how much fun you can have when using tools made for your skill level. My hands felt safer, I was enjoying myself so much more, and the snacks never hurt! Certainly, I think they taste better when you defeat them yourself. It really felt like the tools I was holding were made for me, just like so many of my expertly crafted handmade Japanese knives. I have always appreciated handmade tools, and the experience and skill that Jason puts into each of these incredible pieces astound me. Whether you are a fellow oyster enthusiast or you have friends who are, give these incredible tools a try! 

    Back to blog
       Maddie

    Maddie

    After nine years of building stages and setting up lighting for live events and concerts, Maddie finally decided to hang up her steel toes and find something more stable. Knifewear sounded like the perfect fit for someone raised by foodies. Years of building came in handy for helping to make the Toronto store come together from the ground up. Having been a customer of Knifewear for a long time she was excited to have the chance to help others to find the knives she’s been enjoying for so long. An artist, dead head, Trekkie and foodie - you can always find Maddie diving head first into a new project or adventure.